And since the West--California especially--will be the prime testing ground of our multicultural future, "can we maintain our tradition of democracy, constitutionalism and Western law" even as we accommodate other traditions and other cultures?
Jefferson also hoped that trade relations could be established with the Indians, many of whom still continued to trade directly Patricia nelson limerick frontier thesis the British in Canada. This view dominated religious historiography for decades.
The Lewis and Clark Expedition was organized soon after the Purchase to map and explore the wonders of this new frontier-and hopefully to find a river passage to the Pacific and hence to Asia. So the first frontier of hope was joined by a second frontier of mystery and banishment. From part of a series of graduate papers I wrote almost decades ago.
It did, however, have one national purpose. Martin Ridge argues that the New Western Historians merely reflect the counter-culture mentality of the late s.
The vast extent of land was not initially seen as farming land.
But certainly the tone of anger has modulated: North America and Southern Africa Compared, ed. Many Turnerians and neo-Turnerians have reacted with a counter-offensive.
Lewis and Clark reported that the Louisiana Purchase was a tough, rugged land. It explained why the American people and American government were so different from their European counterparts.
To Limerick and other new western historians what the rapacious white settlers had not marginalized, the rapacious federal government did. Quoted in William H. Historians of the future have a major task ahead of them in trying to see how Alaska fits in with other American frontiers or differs from them.
The only difference between the Turnerians and the New Western Historians, is that in this new story, whites are now the bad guys.
Historian, Scholar, Teacher New York: All three authors, to varying degrees, consider American culture especially capitalism exploitative and wasteful. I can find little future reference that he ever made to Alaska.
In her book Legacy of Conquest, she tried to reverse Turner and dealt more with the concepts of banishment and conquest, than of hope and triumph. It contained Indian inhabitants engaged in fur trading with Caucasians.
Yale University Press, There, I have to part company, but in a friendly way.
Richard Hofstadter, The Progressive Historians: The way these frontiers have been acquired has differed. Limerick struggles to see the modern West as a continuation of older patterns--attitudes about land and nature, about race, even about progress: However, others viewed this interpretation as the impetus for a new wave in the history of United States imperialism.
Is this the way to hook kids on history? It is difficult to separate their environmental views from those concerning the economy. Jefferson hoped that a river passage could be found that would connect the eastern United States with the Pacific Ocean.
So this third frontier became in many ways the most contradictory frontier. Sheldon Jackson, an American missionary to Alaska, feared that the Indians would be marginalized by white settlers who would steal their land.
There they could wait for a longer process of assimilation. Middle Ground, argues that the West should not be seen as just a place; it is also a process—the process of radically different cultures clashing and learning to adapt to one another.
University Press of Kansas, Limerick asserts the notion of a "New Western History" in which the American West is treated as a place and not a process of finite expansion. And while many of us experience a strange disorientation when we travel inland from the West Coast--toward the Sierra, the Mojave, the Badlands, toward the great reservations, toward Phoenix and Grand Junction and Salt Lake, going to a West a frontier?
It is a thesis that has been respected in the historical circle for many years. This American character that came from the frontier then became the trademark for the nation. But most of his co-revisionists scrabble for cohesion.
One reason the New Western History has failed to displace [it] in the popular imagination is that it lacks an equally gripping and ultimately satisfying narrative. Faragher, Rereading Frederick Jackson Turner, Their revisionism is, of course, closely linked with the larger culture wars that have agitated--some would say afflicted--a great many other things, inside the academy and out:Author: Patricia Limerick.
shifting site of interactions between competing groups and one that perhaps most comprehensively undermines Jackson's frontier thesis. In addition, Limerick points to the presence of Asian immigrants and how they were a part of the tremendous racial diversity that made prejudice so complex and fluid in the West.
Patricia Nelson Limerick isn’t setting out to discredit Frederick Jackson Turner as an historian and scholar.
And it isn’t that she believes his influential “Frontier Thesis” was without merit. On the contrary, she describes Turner as a “scholar with intellectual courage, an innovative.
"Meeting of Frontiers" Conference. Turner's Frontier Thesis was the prevailing view of the frontier taught in American schools and colleges until the mids.
There were (and are) entire books and readers for classroom use devoted extensively to the Turner Thesis.Patricia Nelson Limerick. In her book Legacy of Conquest. Start studying Essays. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools.
Search. Create. Patricia Nelson Limerick. the frontier is supposed to be a free, democratic, Americanized place, it is in. Patricia Nelson Limerick Patricia Nelson Limerick (born May 17, ) is an American historian, author, lecturer and teacher, considered to be one of the leading historians of the American West. In she became the Colorado State Historian. Member feedback about Frontier Thesis: History of United States expansionism.
Revolvy. Patricia Nelson Limerick, “What on Earth is the New Western History?”, chapter in Trails: Toward a New Western History, ed. by Patricia Nelson Limerick, Clyde A. Milner II, and Charles Rankin (Lawrence: University Press of Kansas, ),Download