If the Iliad is a myth, meant to impart societal values within an oral society what does this reaction tell us? Merely saying that something is the case does nothing to show why it is the case or to prove that it is the case. Havelock expands on this for us.
The answer would seem to lie in ritualized utterance. From a purely historic standpoint then,there is little to no proof that the events of The Iliad are historically accurate in the modern definition of the term.
Be sure to edit and proofread your paper s. If it works, that is, if it forces us to change our minds and hearts, gives us new hope, and compels us to live more fully, it is a valid myth This is very important for a society based in orality; for a society to function, it must have a way of imparting its history and values from generation to generation, and in such a way that it is easy to retain, recall and impart.
While it is true that the story of The Iliad is from a preliterate society, there is little else that we can verify historically about it. However that may not matter much, if at all. If, however it does not give us new insight into the deeper meaning of life, it has failed.
E to shortly after Troy collapsed. What kind of language can supply this need and still remain oral?
What functions does it serve, and how well does it serve them? Why does it work so well within the world of the Odyssey? It is obviously not what was expected, and as Phoenix and then Ajax make clear it is considered unbecoming of any warrior to turn from the battlefield and leave his comrades behind, let alone one of such a caliber as Achilles.
Consider how one of the following groups is portrayed in the Odyssey you may also compare the handling in the Iliad if you wish: Phoenix comes second, giving Achilles a passionate plea as a surrogate father, one who brought Achilles up and does not wish to see him so dishonored.
It is always acceptable to narrow the topic down to a discussion of a specific passage or example and its relation to the larger issue at hand. Odysseus even goes the extra mile to remind Achilles how much honor and glory he will achieve in the eyes of his fellow warriors.
Remember that assertion is not evidence.
We are free to consider the Iliad as an attempt to chronicle early history, however the archeological record does not fully support this. Odysseus is the first to speak, offering up the splendor which Agamemnon has promised.
If you devise a topic of your own, it should be similar in scope and complexity to the ones below and from the first two response papers. But what is the society in which this is being presented?
Discuss xenia as a theme, focusing on both good and bad examples of guest-host relationships and obligations. See the Plagiarism section of the course syllabus.
Given his purpose in that narration, why should we trust it any more than his other stories? For a longer response you might consider comparing two of these individuals. What function do they serve in the narrative he is telling?The resulting book offers new insights, both into individual instances of Iliadic reception in particular historical contexts, but also into the workings of a complex story tradition.
The centrality of the Iliad within the wider Trojan War tradition is shown to be a function of conscious engagement not only with Iliadic content, but also with.
Find great deals on eBay for iliad and odyssey new. Shop with confidence. And research papers the function of book four within the iliad by homer The book.
the Phoenicians or the Greeks? Dione Three goddesses from the Parthenon east pediment.
although the term has also been loosely used to describe novels. In Book IX of the Iliad an embassy from Agamemnon tries to convince Achilles to return to battle against the Trojans and fails; Achilles refuses to return to battle, to the shock of those around him and presumably the audience as well.
In doing this perhaps we can begin to understand the original purpose of this book within the Iliad, as it. Start studying Iliad Books Two, Three, Four ENG Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Homer and the Poetics of Hades offers a new and unique approach to the Iliad and, more particularly, the Odyssey through an exploration of the role and function of the Underworld as a poetic resource permitting an alternative perspective on the epic past.Download